A mom shared with me that her 5 year old son, Liam, was adamant that he didn’t want to be checked by the doctor at a recent visit with the pediatrician. With lots of support and mom’s award-winning patience, he begrudgingly participated in his physical exam - but with his own terms and conditions (of course).
Many strong willed kids (SWKs) are pretty sensitive about who they share their ‘bubble space’ with. Yet, in our "do-whatever-it-takes-to-fit-in-and-gain-acceptance" society, a child with strong personal boundaries sticks out like a sore thumb.
Having personal boundaries - especially when you're a child - seems like a real rebel move.
But we don't tend to appreciate rebellious children. We'd rather have robot kids who clap, sit, and move...right when Simon Says.
Beneath the surface, Liam isn't a strong willed child, resistant just to be resistant.
He's a brave little boy who's unafraid to honor his limits, and pushes all of the adults in his life to search for new ways to gain his cooperation.
As a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist who specializes in perinatal, infant, and early childhood mental health, I'm trained to use a developmental lens to understand the meaning behind children’s behaviors. This ensures that children are not pathologized for expected behavior, and are instead given the benefit of the doubt as often as we possibly can.
The pediatrician on the other hand…he was concerned about “oppositional defiant disorder.”
Give me a break.
Why would we scare parents…when what we all really need is compassion and support?
We are deeply conditioned to perceive any push-back from a child - especially a SWK - as if it’s clinical and diagnosable…when in reality, it often isn’t.
Don’t get me wrong - sometimes there is underlying neurodivergence, trauma, or family stressors that need to be properly addressed.
And sometimes…they’re just being authentic to themselves.
Some kids just aren’t as jaded by the societal conditioning we’ve all fallen prey to:
- ...be exactly what others expect you to be.
- …do exactly what others expect you to do.
- …sacrifice your authentic self for the masked self that is more tolerable to the rest of us.
This has got to stop.
And I know that because you’re here…you probably agree with me.
Our SWKs deserve a liberated life…free from the harmful conditioning that their way of existing is somehow problematic or bad.
We need to meet our SWKs where they’re at…and help guide them toward more emotional regulation, openness to collaborate, and the expert problem-solving abilities that we know they’re completely capable of.
We can support them without stifling their fire, and help them cultivate their innate passions, ambitions, and desires into something quite spectacular.
Trust me - I know how exhausted you are. And I promise you this: your child isn't trying to make your life harder.
They’re trying to be seen, heard, and understood.
They need discipline that teaches...not punishes.
And they need boundaries that guide...not control.
⭐️ An invitation to join me LIVE: I host a Parenting Strong-Willed Kids Monthly Support Group the first Wednesday of every month, exclusively inside the Conscious Mommy Community. Join me to learn what to do when your SWK resists you over every little thing, why this child is so darn triggering for you personally, and how to handle their fierce need for autonomy without damaging your relationship. See you inside!
Let’s explore how to discipline a strong-willed child without punishment, shame, or yelling...and build a lasting, truly secure relationship in the process.
What Is a Strong-Willed Child?
A strong-willed child is not “bad,” “manipulative,” or “out of control.” They are persistent, passionate, independent, and often deeply intuitive. They usually have a strong sense of justice and an even stronger desire for autonomy.
They also tend to resist authority that doesn’t feel earned or respectful, which can make parenting them feel like one long power struggle.
But here’s the truth: strong-willed children are wired to lead. And they need guidance that supports - not suppresses - that inner spark.
Why Traditional Discipline Doesn’t Work
Time-outs, threats, consequences, and punishments may stop behavior in the moment, but they often create more resistance over time, especially with SWKs. Why?
Because these tactics aim to control rather than connect.
And when a child with a strong will feels controlled, they dig in deeper. You might find yourself thinking:
- “My 7-year-old doesn’t care about consequences.”
- “My child doesn’t respond to discipline.”
- “What do I do when punishment doesn’t work?”
The answer? Shift your mindset from compliance to connection. From punishment to problem-solving.
Discipline Actually Means Teaching
Discipline shares its roots with the word “disciple,” meaning to teach. When we discipline from a place of teaching - not punishing - we create the conditions for cooperation, emotional regulation, and mutual respect.
(P.S.: I dedicate 2 full chapters to discipline and power struggles in my book, Parent Yourself First, which has already helped thousands of families break free from the traditional "My way or the highway" approach to parenting and find true personal healing and thus more whole relationships with their children. Purchase, download, listen, borrow - please enjoy however it suits you best!)
A collaborative approach to discipline is especially essential for strong-willed kids who are constantly testing the boundaries between dependence and independence.
So what does effective discipline look like in practice?
1. Set Clear, Collaborative Boundaries
Strong-willed children need structure, but they also crave agency. That’s why collaborative boundaries work best. These are limits that are clear and firm, but created with your child’s input.
It could sound like:
“The doctor needs to check your body to make sure you’re healthy. You get to choose what she checks first: your ears or your eyes.”
This gives your child a sense of control within a non-negotiable framework, meeting both your need for follow-through and their need for autonomy.
2. Shift From Power Struggles to Problem-Solving
When a child digs in their heels, it’s tempting to double down. But escalation rarely leads to resolution.
Instead, name the challenge and invite your child into the solution:
“You don’t want to leave the park, and we need to get home for dinner. Let’s come up with a plan together. Do you want to leave now and pick the music in the car, or play for five more minutes and then race me to the car?”
This approach preserves their dignity while still honoring the boundary. You’re guiding, not controlling.
3. Use Natural Consequences Thoughtfully
Consequences don’t have to be punitive. In fact, the most effective consequences are natural and logical, not imposed.
If a child refuses to wear a jacket, they might feel cold. That discomfort teaches more than any threat ever could.
But make sure the consequence isn’t a setup or a “gotcha.” For example, let’s say your strong-willed child refuses to put on their shoes before leaving the house. You say, “Fine, then you’re not going to the birthday party.”
This might feel like a natural response in the moment, but it’s not a natural consequence. It’s a withdrawal of something meaningful in an effort to regain control. It’s punitive, emotionally loaded, and often escalates the power struggle. It can also leave your child feeling confused, ashamed, or mistrustful.
A natural consequence keeps the experience connected to the behavior, and supports learning.
“We need to leave in five minutes. Your shoes must be on to go to the birthday party. It's your choice, bud.”
Now, you’re holding a clear, non-negotiable boundary: shoes are required for the party. The consequence isn’t imposed or punitive. It’s simply a condition of participation.
And by saying “It’s your choice,” you’re giving your child a sense of autonomy within that boundary, which helps reduce power struggles and invites cooperation.
The goal isn’t suffering...it’s learning. Support them through the experience and reflect together afterward.
4. Help Them Understand Their “Sticky Thoughts”
Strong-willed kids often get stuck in repetitive thought loops - what I call “sticky thoughts.” When they can’t let go of an idea (especially during a meltdown), their nervous system is often overwhelmed. They get stuck in fight, freeze, and flee...sometimes all at the exact same time.
Here’s a simple way to help:
“Your thoughts are looping and making it hard to think clearly. Let’s shift gears. What’s one thing you can hear right now? Let's listen to it closely. What's one thing you see? What do you like about it? What's one thing you can touch? Let's touch it together and see what it feels like.”
This sensory grounding helps their brain transition out of their nervous system survival responses (i.e.: fight, flight, freeze, fix) and back into a safe, secure connection with you - what we call co-regulation.
5. Prioritize Emotional Coaching Over Behavior Correction
Behavior is communication. And strong-willed children use a lot of (sometimes difficult) behavior to communicate loudly when they feel misunderstood.
Instead of rushing to correct the behavior, pause and get curious:
- What’s their unmet need?
- What’s their deeper fear?
- What's happening around them that might not feel safe?
Be mindful of the environment, name the emotion, hold the limit, and validate their experience. This builds emotional intelligence, which far exceeds obedience in terms of your child's overall health and wellness.
But What If My Child Still Doesn’t Listen?
Many parents worry that positive discipline won’t “work.” But it depends on what you mean by “work.”
If you mean instant compliance, then no - this approach to discipline for strong-willed children won’t always “work” the way you hope. But if you mean long-term respect, trust, cooperation, and emotional health?
Then yes. This works.
And it starts with you.
Final Thoughts: Your Child’s Strong Will Is Not a Flaw
Strong-willed children are here to challenge the status quo. To think for themselves. To question authority. That might be inconvenient at bedtime - but it’s an incredible asset for life.
In fact, I cannot think of anything more important to nurture within our children at this exact moment in history. In fact, it's today's strong-willed kids who will ensure that our future looks brighter, more loving, more fair, and more just.
Your job isn’t to crush their fire. It’s to channel it.
You've got the tools. I've got the support, and all that's left is your daily practice. Never forget: you're built for this, conscious parents. I'm so proud of you!
Never miss a new post. Sign up for the Conscious Connection and get our newsletter delivered to your inbox every week, as well.
Relevant Resources:
🔗 Parenting Strong Willed Kids Exclusive Access inside the Conscious Mommy Community
📘Parent Yourself First: In stores now – order your copy and learn how to Raise Confident, Compassionate Kids By Becoming the Parent You Wish You’d Had. The guidance is practical, actionable, and straightforward. Your path to healing starts now.
